On Monday, August 11th, Magic Head Designer Mark Rosewater published his "State of Design" article for 2025. In his article, which recaps the good and bad of the sets from the past year, Rosewater covered Standard-legal set design from Bloomburrow through Final Fantasy. What worked well? What could Wizards of the Coast do better? Read on, and we'll explore all of this.
<h2>Bloomburrow</h2>
For starters, let's look at the good things that Mark Rosewater expanded upon regarding Bloomburrow. To begin, Bloomburrow did well in terms of its mechanics. Many of the interconnecting lines between mechanical design and its translation to the flavor themes were spot-on, according to Rosewater.
However, when it came to lore and flavor issues, interestingly, Rosewater notes that many players' feedback was critical of the number of animals represented, or the kinds of animals in the setting. This complaint seems to have run the gamut between "too many/few animals" and certain thoughts on frogs versus turtles, et cetera. Furthermore, some animal races were seen as either overpowered in certain formats (such as Mice in Standard) or off in some fashion (like Rats).
<h2>Duskmourn: House of Horror</h2>
Next, Mark Rosewater took a look at Duskmourn: House of Horror. This more modern horror setting did well in many aspects. However, it failed in what Rosewater refers to as "mundane modernity," or what many players see as the aesthetic use of blue jeans, sneakers, and the like. This appears to have been a very common complaint regarding the set. However, many of the other aspects of the flavor for Duskmourn did very well among players, according to Rosewater.
Mechanically, while the set lent itself to a stellar Limited environment overall, the mechanics were seemingly a bit much for many players. There were a lot of different mechanics to keep track of, including Rooms. That said, Rooms were the mechanic from Duskmourn that Rosewater purports he got the most compliments about.
<h2>Foundations</h2>
Rosewater then went on to discuss Foundations. He praised it as "What a Core Set should look like," as "meat-and-potatoes Magic," and "classic Magic" in feeling. However, as high of a mark as Foundations received by players, there were a couple of issues that players emoted to Rosewater in feedback. For one, players expressed concerns about the longevity of Foundations in Standard. Certain card choices needed to be dialed back because Foundations is a 5-year Standard-legal set. As such, Rosewater brought up the ways <a class="edhrecp__link-a" content="Llanowar Elves" href="#" target="_blank">Llanowar Elves</a> warps any format it's in, as well as <a class="edhrecp__link-a" content="Omniscience" href="#" target="_blank">Omniscience</a> bringing the potential for broken combos. As a consequence, Limited also suffered.
<h2>Aetherdrift</h2>
Rosewater then discussed Aetherdrift. It seems that Rosewater views Aetherdrift as a failed design. While players praised the set for its use of the planar settings as the background for the plot, they also didn't seem to have enjoyed the racing plot. Rosewater noted that players liked the settings far more than the overuse of Vehicles and racing tropes. Furthermore, the card pool from Aetherdrift is too weak for the majority of meaningful Constructed play.
<h2>Tarkir: Dragonstorm</h2>
This brings Rosewater to Tarkir: Dragonstorm. Overall, Tarkir: Dragonstorm was a much better set in many players' eyes than the previous set. Flavorwise, it was awesome. The clans and dragons were designed exquisitely from a creative standpoint. However, there was a slight issue in that the original Dragonlords of the Dragons of Tarkir timeline were absent.
Mechanically, Dragonstorm was also a relative hit. It proved that Wizards of the Coast's Design team can craft three-color-focused sets well. This has been a longstanding challenge for them, so it's good to see them tackle this. Otherwise, Limited suffered yet again as people either had to draft red-white Aggro, or a four-to-five color deck focused primarily on green.
<h2>Final Fantasy</h2>
Finally, Mark Rosewater touched upon the Final Fantasy set. While capturing sixteen games in one set was a huge task, Rosewater believes the team did a fantastic job of delivering. However, even if this is the case, many players felt that some of their favorite elements were missing from the set. Beyond this, the flavor of the set felt a little too scattered for many players.
Mechanically, Rosewater had no "lessons" to learn from Final Fantasy, it seems. All of the lessons were largely with the Creative side of things, or logistically. He mentions something about the "layouts" of the Through The Ages bonus sheet, which was slightly harder to read at times. This is valid, but overall, Mark Rosewater's praise for the mechanics of the set bodes well for its implied reception.
The other thing that Rosewater touched on here was that players still seem apprehensive about the Universes Beyond initiative. This is especially true, it seems, with Standard's integration of the licensed sets. Whether players will be able to better acclimate to this new normal in time remaisn to be seen, but it seems that for now, that's here to stay.
<h2>State of Design 2025, in a Nutshell</h2>
This, of course, was just a recap of the notes that Mark touched upon with his State of Design article. There is much more nuance to what he wrote, so if you want to read it, <a href="https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/making-magic/state-of-design-2025">you can do so here</a>.
But let's hear from you now, dear readers. What were your favorite parts of Magic's set design between Bloomburrow and Final Fantasy? What do you think Wizards of the Coast could have done better? Sound off below!

Magic's State of Design 2025 Article, Recapped

<a class="edhrecp__link-a" content="Drought" href="#" target="_blank">Drought</a> | Illustrated by <a href="https://www.nenethomasart.com/">NeNe Thomas</a>
&nbsp;
For the past few sets, Magic: The Gathering has had a profound lack of flavor text. Compared with expansions sets from the 2000s and 2010s, the past year or so suffered from a distinct level of <a href="https://commandersherald.com/solitaired-study-declares-magic-worlds-most-complex-tabletop-game/">rules complexity</a> and mechanical creeping. But according to Magic Head Designer Mark Rosewater, the end of the flavor text drought is just beyond the horizon.
<h2>Mark Rosewater's Statement on Flavor Text</h2>
On Wednesday, August 6th, a Tumblr user asked Rosewater about the current lack of flavor text on most cards in recent years. This was noted especially for "fancy cards" that lacked reminder text. Rosewater replied, "We are making a conscious effort to prioritize having more cards with flavor text."
<div class="tumblr-post" data-href="https://embed.tumblr.com/embed/post/t:DfYWVw3OWM7GYSz0pPuL-Q/791164763967242240/v2" data-did="da39a3ee5e6b4b0d3255bfef95601890afd80709" ><a href="https://www.tumblr.com/markrosewater/791164763967242240/is-it-possible-that-we-could-see-more-flavor">https://www.tumblr.com/markrosewater/791164763967242240/is-it-possible-that-we-could-see-more-flavor</a></div>
<script async src="https://assets.tumblr.com/post.js?_v=38df9a6ca7436e6ca1b851b0543b9f51"></script>
The present reality is that yes, flavor text is on a strict decline. With the game growing more and more complex with each passing year, there's so little room for flavor text now. However, if this is to change, it will only do so slowly and gradually overall. After all, the Magic Design team works roughly two and a half years ahead of a set's release.
<h2>Thoughts in the Notes Section</h2>
Nevertheless, this statement, as brief as it is, bodes well for fans of the story of each set. One especially grateful Tumblr user left a note on this statement, saying to Mark Rosewater directly, "I don’t have all the thanks this deserves, but take all the thanks I can give. Regardless, I’ll be sending more on a daily basis."
Another Tumblr user added, "Please add more flavor text. It is especially annoying for me when one card out of a cycle of five doesn’t have flavor text because it is wordier than the other four. It breaks the feel of the cycle." This is a sentiment that rings true to many Magic players, to be sure.
So now, let's hear from you, dear readers. Do you want Magic to eschew complexity in favor of lore and flavor text? Sound off below!

Mark Rosewater: Flavor Text Drought Will Soon Lift

<a class="edhrecp__link-a" content="Omniscience" href="#" target="_blank">Omniscience</a> | Illustrated by <a href="https://www.jasonchanart.com/">Jason Chan</a>
Magic: The Gathering Head Designer Mark Rosewater is a valuable source of information about the game's design process from the back-end. Rosewater has stated plenty of interesting factoids that turned out to be cleverly disguised hints at the game's future. On Wednesday, August 6th, Rosewater replied to a Tumblr user on <a href="https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/">Blogatog</a>, his personal Tumblr account:
<div class="tumblr-post" data-href="https://embed.tumblr.com/embed/post/t:DfYWVw3OWM7GYSz0pPuL-Q/791123005432610816/v2" data-did="da39a3ee5e6b4b0d3255bfef95601890afd80709" ><a href="https://www.tumblr.com/markrosewater/791123005432610816/since-universes-beyond-sets-dont-usually-have">https://www.tumblr.com/markrosewater/791123005432610816/since-universes-beyond-sets-dont-usually-have</a></div>
<script async src="https://assets.tumblr.com/post.js?_v=38df9a6ca7436e6ca1b851b0543b9f51"></script>
The user asked Mark if we will soon be receiving more planeswalker cards in the future to compensate for the distinct, decided lack of them in the Universes Beyond crossover sets. Rosewater replied with a simple, direct, telling "Yes.".
A single-word answer doesn't always give quite a lot of details as to the process behind the answer. However, note that this question was direct and was answered directly as well. This is good news for fans of the card type and fans of the Planeswalker characters in the story.
<h2>A Caveat About Mark Rosewater's "Yes." Response</h2>
However, as Universes Beyond sets are due to release with the same frequency as Universes Within sets, it is entirely possible that the number of planeswalker cards won't increase per year. Even so, it's fun to think about this. Furthermore, not all Planeswalkers in the Magic story will necessarily get cards associated with them.
Ultimately, this news may not come as a surprise to anyone, but it's a good reminder of the backbone of Magic's overarching story. The game is nothing without the original concepts behind Planeswalkers, either in the story or within the game's mechanics. Love them or hate them, planeswalker cards are here to stay, and Mark Rosewater's "Yes." answer makes that distinctly clear.
And now, let's open the floor to you, dear readers. Are you a fan of the planeswalker card type? Do you want Wizards of the Coast to print more planeswalkers in the future? And furthermore, who are you favorite Planeswalker characters in the story? Sound off in the comments below!

Mark Rosewater: Planeswalker Cards To Be More Frequent Again

<h6 style="text-align: right;"><a class="edhrecp__link-a" content="Storm, Force of Nature" href="#" target="_blank">Storm, Force of Nature</a> | Illustrated by <a href="https://www.instagram.com/magali_villeneuve/?hl=en">Magali Villeneuve</a></h6>
&nbsp;
A few days ago, Magic Head Designer Mark Rosewater addressed some concerns about the <a href="https://commandersherald.com/spider-man-set-confirmed-to-have-no-commander-decks/">lack of Commander decks</a> for Marvel's Spider-Man. According to Rosewater, Spider-Man was too small of a set initially to make a Commander precon tied to the set. However, this doesn't rule out any chances of future Marvel properties getting a Commander tie-in.
<a href="https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/790142262356099072/why-doesnt-spider-man-have-any-commander-decks">On a Blogatog post</a> from Rosewater dated Saturday, July 26th, 2025, a Tumblr user asked the designer why we weren't getting Commander decks for the upcoming Marvel's Spider-Man. To this, Rosewater replied:
<blockquote>As I’ve explained in other posts, it started as something different than what it ended up. We had some ability to adapt it, but there simply wasn’t the ability timewise to add additional products that weren’t originally planned. There will be Marvel-themed Commander decks made in the future.</blockquote>
<div class="tumblr-post" data-href="https://embed.tumblr.com/embed/post/t:DfYWVw3OWM7GYSz0pPuL-Q/790142262356099072/v2" data-did="da39a3ee5e6b4b0d3255bfef95601890afd80709" ><a href="https://www.tumblr.com/markrosewater/790142262356099072/why-doesnt-spider-man-have-any-commander-decks">https://www.tumblr.com/markrosewater/790142262356099072/why-doesnt-spider-man-have-any-commander-decks</a></div>
<script async src="https://assets.tumblr.com/post.js?_v=38df9a6ca7436e6ca1b851b0543b9f51"></script>
This dispels many doubts of there being thematic Commander precons based on Marvel in the future. However, it also sheds more light on Spider-Man. The interaction shown above highlights that the set was much smaller than it is now. This, in turn, gives the implication that Marvel's Spider-Man was slated to have Beyond Boosters. Because Universes Beyond: Assassin's Creed was largely seen as a commercial failure for players, players today speculate that this upcoming set changed its tune at the last minute to accommodate that shift.
While we won't be getting Commander decks for your friendly neighborhood web-slinging superhero, Rosewater has assured players that Marvel Commander decks will come in some capacity. Below is a very short shortlist of possible Marvel properties we may get Commander decks for:
<ul>
<li>Avengers</li>
<li>X-Men</li>
<li>X-Force</li>
<li>Fantastic Four</li>
</ul>
So now, with this in mind, we'd love to open the floor to you, dear readers! Are there any specific Marvel properties that you'd like to see get Commander decks? And while anything is mutable until release, do you stand by Mark Rosewater's statement regarding these precons? Sound off in the comments below!

maro

Magic's State of Design 2025 Article, Recapped

Mark Rosewater: Flavor Text Drought Will Soon Lift

Mark Rosewater: Planeswalker Cards To Be More Frequent Again

Mark Rosewater Confirms Future Marvel Commander Decks

Conditions Allow - Kiyomaro, First to Stand

Commander Showdown — Tishana vs Zegana